Insurance Decision Tool

Move or Stay Calculator

Compare your current housing, insurance, commute, utility, tax, and one-time moving costs against a new address before deciding whether to move.

Compare current vs. new costs Include home and auto insurance Print your worksheet
Thinking about moving? Call 289-812-4225 and quote the new address first

Buying or renting a new home can be emotional. This tool helps add clarity before you sign, waive conditions, or commit to a new address.

Compare Your Current Costs vs. New Address Costs

Enter monthly costs for your current address and the new address. Use annual amounts for auto and home insurance, because insurance quotes are often shown annually.

Privacy note: This worksheet runs in your browser. Your numbers are not submitted to Reliable Insurance Brokers unless you contact us, request a quote, or send them to us yourself.

Monthly housing and living costs

Monthly amount at your current address.
Monthly amount at the new address.
Monthly amount. If annual, divide by 12.
Monthly amount. If annual, divide by 12.
Use 0 if not applicable.
Use 0 if not applicable.
Hydro, gas, water, internet, etc.
Estimate higher if the new home is larger or older.
Monthly parking, permits, or garage fees.
Monthly parking at the new address.
Gas, transit, tolls, parking, extra mileage.
Estimate extra driving, transit, tolls, or parking.
Childcare, storage, maintenance, subscriptions, etc.
New recurring costs created by the move.

Annual insurance costs

Annual premium at your current address.
Annual quote for the new address.
Annual premium at your current address.
Annual quote for the new address.
Do this before committing to the move.
Ask about sewer backup, overland water, service line, and exclusions.

One-time moving and purchase costs

Seller credits, employer relocation, landlord incentive, etc.
Monthly Difference

New address monthly cost minus current monthly cost.

Annual Difference

Recurring cost difference over 12 months.

Insurance Difference

Annual home and auto insurance change.

Break-Even

Estimated time to recover one-time moving costs.

Your move summary

Enter your numbers and calculate to see your estimated move impact.

Current total monthly cost
New address total monthly cost
Total one-time moving or purchase costs
Estimated first-year impact
Estimated three-year impact
Estimated five-year impact

Insurance hot tips

Quote the new address for home and auto insurance before deciding whether the move is worth it.

A comprehensive home insurance quote can reveal important risk signals before you buy.

Buying a home can be emotional. This worksheet is designed to slow the decision down and show the cost difference, coverage difference, and risk difference before you commit.

Important disclaimer: This tool is for general educational purposes only and is not financial, legal, mortgage, real estate, or insurance advice. It does not guarantee insurance eligibility, pricing, or coverage. Your actual costs may vary. Always confirm property tax, condo fees, mortgage payment, closing costs, commute costs, and insurance quotes with the appropriate professional before making a decision.

Hot tips before you move or buy

A lower purchase price or monthly payment does not always mean the move is cheaper. Insurance can reveal risk and cost differences that may not show up in the listing.

Quote insurance before buying

Getting a comprehensive home insurance quote before buying can reveal issues with water coverage, replacement cost, roof age, electrical, plumbing, oil tanks, prior losses, and insurer eligibility.

Water coverage can be a warning sign

If most companies offer only limited water coverage, higher deductibles, capped limits, or no overland water option, that may be a risk signal. It could suggest the property is in an area with higher flood or water-loss exposure.

Auto insurance changes by address

A new postal code can change auto insurance pricing. Always quote the new address before assuming the move saves money.

If insurance companies are limiting water coverage, that is not just an inconvenience. It may be useful data telling you to investigate the property, flood exposure, drainage, grading, sewer history, sump pump, and basement risk more carefully.

How to use this worksheet

Use this page before signing a lease, making an offer, waiving conditions, or deciding that a move is affordable.

Step 1: Enter your current costs

Add your current rent or mortgage, property tax, utilities, commute, parking, home insurance, and auto insurance.

Step 2: Quote the new address

Get actual home and auto insurance quotes for the new address. Do not rely on your current address premium.

Step 3: Print the worksheet

Use the print button to save the worksheet as a PDF or print it for your real estate, mortgage, or family decision-making file.

The goal is clarity. Moving is not just a rent or mortgage decision — it is a total cost and risk decision.

Continue learning before you move

References and Further Reading

Helpful references

These references support the educational information on this page. Always confirm insurance pricing, coverage, and property risk details before making a decision.

Thinking about a new address?

Reliable Insurance Brokers can help you quote home and auto insurance at the new address before you make the move.

Quote the New Address